Top 5 Dishes to Try at Geraldi’s (According to Our Fans)
Published: October 15, 2025 at 114.:30 AM
Whether you’re a regular or it’s your first time walking through our doors, there’s one thing you can count on at Geraldi’s: authentic flavor, generous portions, and real East Coast-style Italian comfort food.
We’ve been serving Portland for over 40 years, and over time, a few dishes have earned a special place in our customers' hearts (and stomachs). If you're not sure what to order, here's a little help — the five most-loved dishes at Geraldi’s, as chosen by the people who keep us cooking: you.
#1 Spicy Italian Sandwich
Three meats. One unforgettable flavor punch.
This fan-favorite sandwich is the ultimate combination of heat, meat, and melty goodness. Stacked high with pepperoni, ham, and salami, the Spicy Italian is layered with provolone cheese and finished with our housemade hot pepper relish. It’s toasted to perfection and packs the kind of bold flavor you’ll crave again tomorrow.
"The Spicy Italian is hands down the best sandwich in Portland. Perfect kick!" – Taylor M., Google review
#2 Classic Pepperoni Pizza
A slice of tradition. Always hits the spot.
Sometimes simple is best — and that’s where our Classic Pepperoni Pizza comes in. With a crispy, hand-tossed crust, tangy tomato sauce, melty mozzarella, and just the right amount of spice from high-quality pepperoni, this pizza never misses.
"Crispy crust, gooey cheese, and the pepperoni curls just right. Perfection." – Josh D., Yelp
#3 Meatball Parmesan Sub
Melty, saucy, cheesy comfort in every bite.
Slow-simmered meatballs, marinara from scratch, and melted provolone come together inside a toasted hoagie roll for one of our most comforting and popular sandwiches. This one is messy in the best way possible — grab extra napkins and dig in.
"The meatballs are tender and full of flavor — reminds me of my Nonna’s cooking." – Angela F., Facebook review
#4 Chicken Parm Sandwich
Crispy chicken, rich marinara, and a whole lot of cheese.
This one’s a customer obsession. We take a crispy, breaded chicken breast, smother it in our signature marinara, and layer on melted mozzarella and provolone before toasting it in a fresh hoagie roll. It’s everything you love about Chicken Parm — in sandwich form.
"Every time I try something new, I still come back to the Chicken Parm. It's unbeatable." – Brian C., Google
#5 Antipasto Salad
A fresh, flavorful break from the carbs — kind of.
When you want something lighter but still packed with flavor, our Antipasto Salad delivers. It’s full of Italian meats, cheese, olives, pepperoncini, fresh veggies, and a zesty house vinaigrett.
"This salad is a full meal. Everything is fresh and flavorful." – Jen P., Yelp
These five dishes are just the beginning. our full menu has something for everyone. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick lunch, picking up dinner for the family, or ordering a late-night slice, Geraldi’s is here to serve it up hot and satisfying every time.
📍 Find us in Portland, Oregon!